
Andrew Bonomolo Won’t Be Shamed Into Silence
After losing a role in Cape Fear Regional Theatre’s Bright Star, the out actor and former adult performer talks about sex work, theater’s double standards, and why he decided to speak out.
The irony is almost too neat to have been scripted. Andrew Bonomolo had been cast in Cape Fear Regional Theatre’s production of Bright Star, the Steve Martin–Edie Brickell musical whose central story turns on a young woman being shamed and forced into secrecy after becoming pregnant. Then, shortly before rehearsals began, Bonomolo says the theater terminated his contract after learning about his own past in adult entertainment. The company did not give him an official reason for the dismissal, and Cape Fear Regional Theatre declined to comment when OUT reported on the story earlier this month.
Bonomolo, a Chapel Hill native who studied musical theater at Elon University before moving to New York, began working on OnlyFans and in adult films after COVID disrupted his plans as a performer. Under the name Troye Jacobs, he built a substantial following and made a living from adult work while continuing to think of theater as his long-term goal. He had stepped away from filming adult content more than a year before the Bright Star job, according to OUT. For Bonomolo, the experience has exposed a fault line in a theater culture that readily celebrates sexual expression onstage while, he argues, still judging performers who have made sexual expression part of their livelihood.
Rather than disappear quietly, Bonomolo went public. In the conversation below, joined at points by his publicist Scott Gorenstein, he describes being called into a meeting shortly before the first rehearsal, the anonymous email he says alerted the theater to his adult work, and the vague contract language that may limit his options for recourse. He also talks about the shock of being dismissed by fellow artists, the response he has received from other performers, and the possibility of returning to OnlyFans. What emerges is less a story about regret than about refusing the premise that there is anything in his past for which he should be ashamed.
QulturVultur: Let’s start at the beginning. How did your acting career begin?
Andrew Bonomolo: I always loved musicals, so I did theater in school. When I went to college, I decided to major in musical theater at Elon University here in North Carolina. Before COVID, I attended Elon for musical theater, and after COVID I moved to New York City and auditioned on and off. I always loved to sing, and I’d also performed locally near Chapel Hill. Growing up, I just knew I wanted to sing and perform.
QulturVultur: Did OnlyFans happen when you were in New York?
Andrew Bonomolo: Correct. After COVID, life was up in the air for me, so I decided to start doing OnlyFans and studio porn. I quickly made quite a good living from it, especially living in New York City. But the goal was always to return to performing and use that work as financial fuel. My dream is to be a performer. It wasn’t until I started auditioning again that I began to feel pushback and judgment from people outside the adult industry about someone working in porn or having an OnlyFans account. In New York, there were a lot of creative people, actors and singers, who did sex work and used OnlyFans. New York was a bubble in that respect.
QulturVultur: You’ve drawn a parallel between what happened to you and Bright Star, whose central character is shamed for being sexual. Do you think that irony was lost on the people who fired you?
Andrew Bonomolo: I don’t think they saw the connection. I really don’t, because I didn’t see it initially either, and I’ve done the show before. I played the same role in a production in Chapel Hill. It wasn’t until I really thought about it that I realized: this is the lead character’s story. She gets pregnant at a young age and is essentially forced into hiding by people who don’t want shame attached to the family name. It was very interesting to draw those parallels and think, “Wow, this theater doesn’t want to be associated with me because of my work,” when essentially the same thing happens to the lead character in the show.
QulturVultur: You had played this role before. Was Cape Fear Regional Theatre hiring you for a professional production?
Andrew Bonomolo: Yes. It’s a professional company in Fayetteville, North Carolina, and there were Equity contracts within the show. They put on very nice productions, and that’s why I was excited to work with them.
QulturVultur: How did you learn that you were being dismissed?
Andrew Bonomolo: The artistic director texted me about an hour before the first rehearsal on the first day and said, “I’d like to meet with you before rehearsal,” without suggesting anything was wrong. I went to meet her, and there was someone else there who I assumed was legal counsel. She simply said, “We’re terminating your contract.” I repeatedly asked why, but I discovered very quickly that they were not going to give me any information. When I asked, “Is this because of prior work?” the phrase they kept repeating was, “I cannot say anything.”
Afterward, while I was packing my car to leave, an assistant at the theater told me off the record that they had received an email that morning alluding to my sex work and making them aware of it. She kept saying, “I’m sorry this happened.” I couldn’t wrap my head around the fact that there was no conversation to be had with me. It was simply: “We’re terminating your contract.”

QulturVultur: Was there a morals clause or anything similar in the contract?
Scott Gorenstein: It’s a very simple line. It doesn’t say much at all, and it leaves them a lot of room for interpretation. Under the reasons for termination, the language reads: “Behavior unbecoming an Actor of the Play as deemed by CFRT.”
Andrew Bonomolo: Especially because it says “as deemed by” Cape Fear Regional Theatre. It’s very vague.
QulturVultur: What kind of recourse do you have to dispute the dismissal or pursue legal action?
Andrew Bonomolo: It’s been tough because North Carolina is an at-will employment state. With that line in the contract, it gives them a lot of power to say what they deem to be behavior unbecoming. That’s why legal recourse has been difficult to assess.
Scott Gorenstein: We’ve had a couple of conversations with employment lawyers, and we probably will again. Andrew has been a little on the fence about how much he wants to pursue recourse. He doesn’t have unlimited resources, it can be difficult to pay for an attorney, and he also has to consider what is best for him professionally. It’s something we’re interested in exploring, but for right now we’re leaving it there.
QulturVultur: How did you feel when they told you?
Andrew Bonomolo: First, I was shocked and upset that this opportunity had been taken from me just like that. But mostly I felt confusion, and that really set in over the next couple of weeks as I started drawing the parallels and thinking about the hypocrisy of being an artist, expressing yourself, and everything musical theater is supposed to stand for. I wasn’t expecting this particular group of artists to judge me the way they did. “Shocking” is the word I would use.
QulturVultur: Do you think the reaction was partly regional, reflecting local attitudes?
Andrew Bonomolo: I realize now that could be part of it. After I posted on social media, a couple of other people said they had worked at this theater and felt they had encountered similar judgments. Whether that was because they were gay, I’m not sure. Fayetteville is in the Bible Belt, and it is a conservative area. Growing up in Chapel Hill, which is much more liberal, I couldn’t imagine something like this happening. I was incredibly shocked.

Troye Jacobs (Instagram)
QulturVultur: Where did you get the strength to come forward so publicly? A lot of people might have internalized the shame.
Andrew Bonomolo: I think that’s what people want you to do. They don’t want you to speak out. The theater did not want me to speak out. The artistic director made that very clear. She said, “If you don’t say anything, we will not say anything.”
QulturVultur: Did you feel they expected you to be ashamed of your adult work?
Andrew Bonomolo: The artistic director made it very clear that she did not want anything said about the situation. But I’m not that kind of person. My goal in speaking out is to make sure no other actor with my history has to go through that at that theater company. I would hate to see another actor who has done sex work audition there and be treated the same way I was.
QulturVultur: Has the theater experienced any pushback over its actions?
Andrew Bonomolo: After I posted on social media, they disabled their comments and blocked me. I know a few people reached out directly by email, and journalists reached out to them for comment. They have given no comment.
Scott Gorenstein: They’ve opted not to comment. They’ve left it at that, and, as Andrew said, they shut down comments on their social media so people can’t post there.
QulturVultur: How are you doing career-wise now? Are you auditioning or hearing from other theaters?
Scott Gorenstein: In terms of offers, no, but everything just happened, and Andrew went on vacation soon afterward. He literally got back yesterday. It’s been a whirlwind.
Andrew Bonomolo: There has been an overwhelming response from fellow actors and other theaters, and that has been inspiring. I definitely want to keep doing theater and keep singing.
QulturVultur: Have you thought about returning to OnlyFans?
Andrew Bonomolo: I’m at a crossroads, but if I do, I won’t have any shame about it. It excites me. It’s fun, freeing and sexually liberating, and there’s an artistic, performative side to it. To make that kind of content and sell it to people, you have to create something. In that sense, there are similarities to theater.
Click here to watch Andrew Bonomolo perform “Over the Rainbow”
For more on Andrew Bonomolo and Troye Jacobs, follow these links:
Andrew Bonomolo on Instagram
Troye Jacobs on Instagram
Troye Jacobs on OnlyFans
Troye Jacobs on Twitter (X)





