
Rex Reed – the First and Last of a Kind
Rex Reed died earlier this week. He was a rarity – a queer media presence who never hid who he was in a time when it could have cost him his career.
By Robert Nesti
In 1969 Rex Reed appeared on The Dick Cavett Show, dressed in a Herringbone jacket and matching vest. “A little ‘Bill Blass’ number here,” he said, and my teen queen gaydar went off. His stylish look, self-confidence, and manner were something network television had never seen before. Here was an out queer man clearly not caring what anyone thought. And he was cute and sexy. Sexy Rexy became his moniker among some. Within seconds, he mentioned June Preisser, a little-known MGM performer from the Judy Garland–Mickey Rooney films, and it was the kind of reference right out of The Boys in the Band. Like the success of that off-Broadway play, Reed’s frequent television appearances marked a cultural shift to a new openness – an acknowledgement of queer culture that had always been on the margins.
And he was everywhere – on Cavett once a week, The Tonight Show, game shows, television and radio interviews, and the best seller lists, where his book of interviews, Do You Sleep in the Nude?, had nestled in a top ranking. In a 1968 Time Magazine piece about him, cattily entitled “Rex Reed: the Hazel-eyed Hatchet Man,” he said he counted 22 appearances on radio and television in one week. This was in addition to writing for the New York Times and New York Magazine. Over his six-decade career he would be the chief arts critic for the New York Daily News for 13 years; film critic for the New York Post for five; and columnist for the New York Observer for 40 years, serving as its film critic and author of the Talk of the Town column. He contributed to Women’s Wear Daily, Esquire, Vogue and GQ, and was even music critic for Stereo Review for seven years. His last film review was published in November in the Observer; his final piece for the paper, a tribute to its founder Arthur L. Carter, appeared in December.
Reed was a queer media presence, but his sexuality was never brought up. And he didn’t see himself as an avatar. When told some fifty years later that he was described as “openly gay” in a speaker’s bureau pamphlet, Reed said that he didn’t know what gay meant until he moved to New York. “Some publicist must have written that. I’ve never been openly anything. … I don’t care what anyone says about me because I have had an incredibly full life and I’ve left no stone unturned or no turn unstoned.”
Reed died earlier this week in his apartment at the Dakota, the storied Upper West Side residence which he bought in 1969 for $30,000. In a 2022 interview on The Originals with Andrew Goldman, he said that Andrew Lloyd Webber had asked to buy his unit for $8,000,000. He declined. “Where am I going to go?” he said.
Reed introduced a new style of celebrity interview and was part of the New Journalism that burst on the scene in the mid-1960s along with Tom Wolfe, Gay Talese, Joan Didion, and Pauline Kael – the esteemed film critic; but, unlike them, he had no intellectual pretensions and said he only wrote what he saw. Nonetheless, when Wolfe published an anthology of pieces by these journalists, he included Reed’s infamous interview with Ava Gardner. “Rex Reed raised the celebrity interview to a new level through his frankness and his eye for social detail. He has been a master at capturing a storyline in the interview situation itself,” Wolfe wrote.
Judy Garland, who interviewed him while subbing for Merv Griffin, introduced him as a man “famous for saying terrible things about most people,” which he quickly corrected: “No. Mostly terrible people.” What he understood was whether it was a review or an interview, the writing needed to be vivid and alive – a performance. For him glamour as a subject was worthy of serious attention. He understood that a profile of Ava Gardner or Barbra Streisand or Buster Keaton was not fluff — it was cultural history written in real time, by someone who had actually been in the room.
And he interviewed them all, often to their chagrin. His famous 1966 interview with Barbra Streisand began with: “One thing about Barbra Streisand: to know her is not necessarily to love her.” He went on to complain that she was three-and-a-half hours late for the interview, “plods into the room, falls into a chair with her legs spread out, tears open a basket of fruit, bites into a green banana.” She then said, you’ve got 20 minutes. When she gave a 1973 interview for the Times, they gave her quote approval, and she spent some of it complaining about Reed.
When Blow-Up was the hot film of 1966, he interviewed director Michelangelo Antonioni, but he was far from taken in. “If there is anything more excruciating than sitting through a Michelangelo Antonioni film it’s sitting through a Michelangelo Antonioni interview. Like scenes from one of his movies the experience is a symphony of tedium.”
Reed made a life-long enemy of Frank Sinatra when he called his daughter Nancy “a cocktail waitress” and compared the then somewhat overweight singer to “the Pillsbury Dough Boy.” When Sinatra married Mia Farrow, he quipped, “Hah! I always knew Frank would end up in bed with a boy.” He was merciless even with those he called his friends, such as Sinatra’s ex-wife Ava Gardner whom he called ‘a dearest, dearest friend,’ then described her as “completely drunk” in a 1967 interview. She was still bristling from the interview 20 years later when she told the Chicago Tribune that “This son of a bitch is either at your feet or at your throat.”
When Warren Beatty made Bonnie and Clyde, he reluctantly spoke with Reed. Beatty was completely uncooperative, obsessively protective of his image, and agonizingly slow to answer questions. The piece became famous not for what Beatty said, but for how Reed brutally satirized Beatty’s evasiveness and nomadic lifestyle. “Interviewing Warren is like asking a hemophiliac for a pint of blood.”
He could also be effusive, especially with performers of a certain age and generation. In 1968 he marveled at Bette Davis’s endearing magnetism, “Froggy-eyed, lipstick-slashed or glowing like a Tiffany lamp, she is exciting enough, even when photographed through gauze, to make the latest youth idols about as interesting as a withered logarithm.” He said that Gwen Verdon was “as rare as blue butterflies, who carry around their own lightning.” He told Garland that her not winning the Oscar for A Star Is Born was one of the great injustices in Hollywood history. And of Broadway/cabaret great Barbara Cook, he would write, “In a musically imperfect world, there is still perfection in the voice of Barbara Cook… Somebody is still singing them with purity and passion. She is Barbara Cook, and she sings them for the angels to applaud.”
And Reed even became close friends with some celebrities. He met Barbara Stanwyck through a practical joke played on him by Truman Capote: while in Hollywood, the writer set Reed up on a hot date on April Fool’s Day. When he arrived at the Beverly Hills Hotel, his date was Barbara Stanwyck. Despite the unusual nature of their meeting, they immediately hit it off, in part because she was impressed with his deep knowledge of her career. They stayed friends right up until her death in 1990. In 1981 talk show host Tom Snyder turned his 90-minute show over to Reed to interview Stanwyck.
He called Angela Lansbury his closest friend from Hollywood. They met in 1957 when Lansbury was filming The Long Hot Summer on location near Baton Rouge and Reed was a student at Louisiana State University. In 1966 he interviewed her for the New York Times, writing: “She’s all heart, and no ego. She’ll let the biggest bores in the world bend her ear all night and feel so sorry for them she’ll invite them for breakfast the next morning. That’s the kind of girl she is.” When Time Magazine asked her about him for the aforementioned 1968 profile, she said: “He has antennae most people haven’t even heard of.” He found her numerous Broadway dressing rooms a sanctuary where she would stock Dr. Pepper just for him and called Reed’s apartment “her memorial” because there were so many photographs of her. And when she died in 2022, the heartbroken Reed said, “I don’t feel like I have friends anymore. They’re all gone.”
It was recently learned Reed was adopted, an only child. His father was in the oil business and the family moved around a lot. Both parents were supportive of his interests. His mother helped shape his intellectual curiosity, taking adult-themed books out of local libraries for him to read. He claims to have seen Gone With the Wind at age 2. When old enough, he would attend movies alone and recalls memorizing Barbara Stanwyck’s filmography. “I knew what to ask her,” he explained. “I asked questions that interested her.”
Despite attending many different schools, he was an exemplary student – All ‘A’s’. He would get a degree in journalism from Louisiana State University, then headed to New York City. But could not find a journalism job, instead took one in the publicity department of Twentieth Century Fox only to be laid-off when the studio cut-back. On a trip to Europe with friends, he attended the Venice Film Festival, where he interviewed Buster Keaton and Jean-Paul Belmondo. On the same day, the NY Times published his Keaton interview and the NY Herald Tribune his with Belmondo, and a journalism star was born. Who knows how accurate his Belmondo interview was since Reed spoke no French and Belmondo no English.
He was a careerist who built a wall around his private life. In 2018 he would say, “Love is not something I’ve been good at. People are intimidated by people with opinions. How do you start looking for a wife or boyfriend at this point? It’s too late. Though it would be nice to find someone handy with a wheelchair, because that day is coming.” But in a piece published this week in the Observer, he spoke of a relationship that lasted 25 years. “His name was Rick Winter, and he ran DRG Records, producing albums including Liza Minnelli’s recording of The Act. After Rick died, there was no one else.”
Like his interviews, his film reviews were controversial. “A loopy, lunkheaded load of drivel” — his verdict on Guillermo del Toro’s The Shape of Water, which won the Academy Award for Best Picture. “Just because he stopped shaving doesn’t mean he can suddenly act,” he said of Keanu Reeves in 2018. On Marlon Brando, he wrote that most of the time the actor sounded like he had “a mouth full of wet toilet paper.” On David Lynch’s Blue Velvet: “one of the sickest films ever made.”
He also held onto opinions that today are mean-spirited, disrespectful, and wrong. Take his 2013 review of Identity Thief, which he described Melissa McCarthy as “humongous,” “tractor-sized,” and a “female hippo.” That was not criticism — it was cruelty dressed up as opinion, and the distinction matters. He ascribed the Oscar win by deaf Children of a Lesser God actor Marlee Matlin to a “pity vote.”
Or the silly argument he had with his Observer editor about Elliot Page. “You changed it, but now it is worse than ever,” he wrote in an email about changing the name to one the actor preferred. “You can’t say—or rather, I can’t say—‘lovely, appealing Elliot Page.’ It is ‘lovely, appealing Ellen Page,’ referring to BEFORE the transition. The way it reads now is positively ridiculous—on NYO, on the Drudge Report, and on Rotten Tomatoes. I wish you would just reinstate the copy the way I wrote it, which is how I meant for it to read and makes perfect sense. But no way can you refer to the man Ellen Page is now as ‘lovely, appealing Elliot Page.’”
He spent years perpetuating the false conspiracy theory that Marisa Tomei’s Oscar for My Cousin Vinny had been awarded by mistake — a claim so persistent that Oscars accounting firm Price Waterhouse was forced to publicly confirm that she had in fact won. He penned a review of Cabin in the Woods so factually inaccurate that a fellow critic documented it being approximately fifty percent wrong about the basic content of the film — describing vampires that did not exist and a video game that was not in the movie.
And let’s not forget his film career. In 1970, Reed made the decision — inexplicable in retrospect, though perhaps not in context — to act in the film adaptation of Gore Vidal’s Myra Breckinridge, playing Myron, the pre-surgery version of the character who becomes Raquel Welch. The film was a catastrophe of such gargantuan proportions that it has never entirely lost its fascination, though it is largely unwatchable. Mae West came out of retirement to steal scenes and sing songs and do whatever she wanted. Raquel Welch gave an interview in which she admitted she had no idea from scene to scene what her character’s motivations were. Gore Vidal disavowed it. Time magazine wrote that “Myra Breckinridge is about as funny as a child molester. It is an insult to intelligence, an affront to sensibility and an abomination to the eye.”
Reed, too, panned Myra Breckinridge. It was, he wrote, “a train wreck.” He would later say about the experience of making it: “Mae West spoke to no one but God. Raquel spoke only to the studio head. The studio head spoke only to God, who relayed messages back to Mae West.”
Or the shoplifting incident. In February 2000, Reed left a Tower Records on the Upper West Side with Mel Tormé, Peggy Lee, and Carmen McRae CDs in his coat pocket without paying for them. He said he forgot. The charges were dropped. When she learned of the incident, Peggy Lee sent him a complete set of her recordings. A gesture that in retrospect was pure Rex Reed.
Reed introduced the probing celebrity interview, a style of writing that exists pretty much on the fringes today. Certainly not in the New York Times where he made his name. He was the first of a kind and, sadly, the last of a kind. And his voice, like it or not, is authentically queer, and gave cover and courage to every queer critic who came after him — every one of us who understood that the way you experience culture is inseparable from who you are, and that pretending otherwise is not professionalism. It is just a different kind of lie.
He put it best himself: “I took the lowest form of journalism—the celebrity interview—and did something with it,” Rex reflected. “For a boy with no money who didn’t know a famous soul to come to New York and make a name in journalism, that was no small achievement.”





