A scene from The Great Gatsby. (Evan Zimmerman)

Opulent Gatsby Isn’t So Much Great
as Just Entertaining

In offering the equivalent of a graphic romance novel, this musicalized Great Gatsby succeeds on its on terms.

By Robert Nesti

Since it went into the public domain in 2021, there have been two musical versions of The Great Gatsby — one called The Great Gatsby, the other Gatsby: An American Myth — and the difference in the titles points to how each creative team approached musicalizing F. Scott Fitzgerald’s most famous novel. The latter, which premiered at the American Repertory Theater two years ago, offered a dark telling of the story, truer to Fitzgerald’s cynical subtext. The Great Gatsby, currently on Broadway and with its touring company at the Citizens Opera House through July 19, approaches the novel with little of its intended irony. It’s hard to take it very seriously because its creative team appears not to have done so. Nonetheless, it’s an opulent spectacle — the kind that critics will berate but audiences love.

The adaptation, by Kait Kerrigan, pretty much follows the contours of the novel: Its narrator, Nick Carraway (Joshua Grosso), arrives in New York in 1922 from the Midwest to find his fortune on Wall Street, but over the summer becomes involved with his mysterious neighbor, the uber-rich Jay Gatsby (Jake David Smith). Gatsby is famous for throwing wild parties in his castle-like mansion that he barely attends. Nick also catches him standing on the dock reaching out to a green light across the bay, the meaning of which becomes clearer as the story unfolds. At one of his parties, Gatsby approaches Nick to be a go-between in rekindling his romance with Daisy Buchanan (Senzel Ahmady), Nick’s cousin, now married to old-money-wealthy Tom Buchanan (Will Branner). At first Nick is reluctant, but when he sees Tom abusing his mistress Myrtle (Lila Coogan), he decides Tom is an asshole (Kerrigan’s word, not Fitzgerald’s) and puts into action the romance between Gatsby and Daisy — and its tragic aftermath.

Kerrigan takes some liberties with the text, turning Nick’s hinted-at attraction to Daisy’s friend Jordan Baker (Leanne Robinson) into an affair and an engagement. In the novel, Fitzgerald hints that they are both queer (and they were in Gatsby: An American Myth), which makes their courtship a bit of a stretch. Kerrigan also ignores how James Gatz became Jay Gatsby — a crucial episode in the novel. This makes him less an enigma and more a character out of romance fiction: hunky, guileless, and a bit simple-minded. This becomes most apparent in the second act in his dealings with the more quick-witted Tom.

Jake David Smith in The Great Gatsby. (Evan Zimmerman

Throughout the dialogue sounds very modern, which makes the show more accessible but distances it from its source. This puts the book very much in keeping with the score (music by Jason Howland; lyrics by Nathan Tysen), which is very pop Broadway. If the songs have any musical theater antecedents, it is the work of Henry Krieger (Dreamgirls, Side Show) in the way they infuse pop styles into Broadway storytelling. There is little period pastiche and just a bit of jazz, mostly in the dance numbers for the busy ensemble. Daisy and Gatsby get a number of power ballads that are pleasant enough and are delivered in a go-for-broke performance style that had many of the Gatsby stans shouting approval. And there are some sharply written numbers that do capture the spirit of the novel: “New Money” offers a cynical overview of the rise of tycoons like Gatsby in the post-WWI years and is quite fetchingly performed by the very talented Leanne Robinson and the ensemble. Later, Howland and Tysen hit the mark with “Made to Last,” a scathing quintet in which the battle lines are clearly drawn between Tom and Gatsby. In it, Tom neatly expresses the hopelessness of Gatsby’s quest: “It’s not about wealth, it’s blood, it’s class / The day you were born, your die had been cast.”

And it is all done up with Art Deco splendor. Paul Tate dePoo III’s production design seems inspired by the lobby of the Chrysler Building, with burnished gold geometric patterns moving in and out to frame the action. At the rear is a large LED screen with beautifully rendered projections that would be right at home in a Gatsby video game. Especially effective are the fireworks that cap a Gatsby party and a ride into New York City with ever-changing vistas in the background. These shifting visual elements are in keeping with the over-the-top style of the musical itself, which is busy, loud, and never dull. Linda Cho’s costumes are as gorgeous as they are extensive — flappers never looked so good. And Cory Pattak’s lighting only enhances its polished, wealthy look.

Dominique Kelley’s busy choreography offers an amalgam of styles — from Bob Fosse to Tommy Tune — and does so with endless energy from the tireless ensemble. Especially good is a second-act tap number that shows what fun a Gatsby party can be. Marc Bruni’s direction moves smoothly from spectacle to more intimate scenes, with strong performances all around. Of the principals, Joshua Grosso makes a personable Nick, and he is paired nicely with Leanne Robinson, very well cast as Jordan Baker, in their invented romance. Jake David Smith makes for a very suave Gatsby; it’s not his fault that he looks a bit clueless in the second act (blame that on the script). He sings beautifully — his second-act solo soars in his full-bodied performance. Senzel Ahmady embodies Daisy’s ambivalence quite well and can hold her own with Smith in their big act-one duet. Will Branner effectively plays Tom as a well-heeled, manipulative creep, and Lila Coogan ably conveys Myrtle’s deep frustrations, especially in her second-act mea culpa.

Gatsby: An American Myth was truer to Fitzgerald, but since its ART production it has changed directors and is on hold for a future staging. This Gatsby only hints at the novel whose greater themes many of us studied in high school English classes. But for most, its superficiality is a plus — romance and spectacle conjoin to make this adaptation a slick entertainment, not much different from its film adaptations. It’s not great, but good enough.

The Great Gatsby continues at the Citizens Opera House, 539 Washington Street, Boston, MA through July 19. For ticket information, visit the Broadway In Boston website at this link. For more on the national tour, visit the show’s website at this link.