
Léa Seydoux Gives Career Defining Performance in Gentle Monster
By Kilian Melloy
Léa Seydoux delivers a career-defining performance (one that will be remembered come awards season) in the Marie Kreutzer-written and -directed Gentle Monster.
Léa Seydoux delivers a career-defining performance (one that will be remembered come awards season) in the Marie Kreutzer-written and -directed Gentle Monster.
When Lucy’s (Seydoux) filmmaker husband Philip (Laurence Rupp) comes staggering home in the grip of a breakdown, Lucy determines that a move to a house in the country is the right move for him, herself, and their young son, Johnny. But new challenges await the family when detectives from the Munich police department arrive at their door with a search warrant and Philip is implicated in horrific crimes involving children.
Shocked, enraged, and thrown into full, fierce protection mode to protect Johnny, Lucy, a concert pianist, struggles to keep her equilibrium even as an important performance looms. Her mother (Catherine Deneuve), also a concert pianist in her day, offers tepid support, and there may be nowhere else for Lucy and Johnny to go except back to the house they share with a man who now seems more stranger than either a father or husband. With the crumbling of one story after another that might explain Philip’s transgression, Lucy’s fear and bewilderment grow.

Meantime, Elsa, one of the detectives assigned the case, struggles with domestic upheaval of her own as her elderly father — in the grip of diminished mental capacity acting out sexually toward his female caregiver — slides deeper into dementia. Lucy’s shock and confusion strikes a chord for Elsa, and the two women share a fragile, fleeting connection as they puzzle over how to protect their loved ones even as they wonder whether they still know major male figures in their lives… or if they ever knew them at all.
Lively with music (Lucy’s oeuvre is classically based, but focused on pop songs) as well as with language (the characters speak a mélange of French, German, and English), the film feels authorially masterful. Kreutzer (who also gave us the well-regarded Corsage) is to be commended. But the film’s substance outweighs even its expert technique: Balanced between defending and denouncing, Gentle Monster examines a little-considered aspect of male misdeeds: The devotion of the women those misdeeds cannot help but affect. A telling moment in the film comes when Lucy is interviewed as to why she performs only popular songs written by men, but her fury and frustration, taken out on a piano during a performance of “Boys Don’t Cry,” serves as a piercing précis for the film’s central thesis that monstrosity, however soft of touch, is never truly gentle.
“Gentle Monster” is in cinemas now and begins streaming at Netflix on November 18.






Leave a Reply